Fiber Plus

The deceptive cruelty of being nice We often mistake being "nice" for being good. As Jefferson Fisher argues, niceness focuses on surface-level pleasantries, while kindness prioritizes the truth. When you avoid delivering bad news because you don't want to be "mean," you are actually prioritizing your own comfort over the other person's need for clarity. This results in a "spaghetti junction" of a conversation where the point is lost, and the recipient is left in an agonizing open loop. Leading with the no The most effective strategy for delivering bad news—whether ending a relationship or declining an invitation—is to start with the "no" first. Most people attempt a "compliment sandwich," layering the blow between soft words. Fisher warns that this is hard to chew. If you start with gratitude, you create a false sense of security. When the blow finally comes, it feels like a betrayal. Instead, state the news immediately: "I cannot make it," or "I am ending this relationship." Managing the cold plunge Difficult conversations are like a cold plunge. The first few seconds are a shock to the system, and your instinct is to flee or bail out. However, if you stay in the water, your breathing steadies and clarity returns. To avoid the "poly-eject" temptation, commit to the hard words early. Once the main point is out, the "mountain" has been crested, and the rest of the conversation can focus on genuine reflection and next steps. Tools for the hard talk To execute these moments with integrity, prepare these three essential elements: * **The Label:** Acknowledge the gravity. "This is going to be hard news." * **The Lead:** State the decision clearly without qualifiers like "but." * **The Kindness:** Once the truth is established, you can offer sincere gratitude for the past without it feeling like a manipulative softening of the blow. The power of the closed loop Uncertainty is more painful than bad news. By being direct, you act with integrity and allow the other person to begin their recovery. You shift from a "nice guy" to a good man, recognizing that disappointment is a required life lesson and an essential tool for leadership and healthy relationships.